Here is my critical review for watchmen (WARNING! SPOILER!):
While I have to appreciate Snyder for all the loops he had to get through (knowing that if he quite, they would have gotten someone who would kill the comic), I still find it, in my opinion WEAK.
If you want to enjoy the movie, abandon all hopes of it being like the comic. Consider the freaking condensed power point of the novel, only hitting the big points, and so lacking in the “OOMPF!” without all the background knowledge.
Now, some of this ranting will be out of place because if they wanted to include it all, it would be an extremely long movie.
To begin: they cut out a lot of the character’s background histories. While I have to keep timing in mind, I still have to complain about this because it doesn’t give enough time to develop the characters from just superheroes with screwed lives, into people you relate to and feel sympathy for. They didn’t really give enough background info about Rorschach, for example. And so, it felt like just a guy who was born messed up, instead of a slow creation of his environment. I really felt cheated without the storyline of Rorschach with his psychiatrist. Not to mention, THEY KILLED my favourite speech in the book, the “this world is not shaped by vague metaphysical beings..”. Not to mention, they changed around the kidnapping scene in Rorschach’s history, that was PIVTOL to his character development (you know—when he goes to save the 6 year old who was kidnapped, only to learn he was too late).
They completely dropped Hollis (first Nite Owl) as a character. He was just there, and then he wasn’t.
While I would have liked more in the Juspecyk’s relationship, or Dan’s obsession with going back to the old times, the movie didn’t suffer without it. So, while it’s nice, it’s possible to touch upon it without all the full info.
And don’t get me started on the scene in which Jon is trapped in the field machine, about to become Manhattan. The two actors who played his friend and his girlfriend lacked any emotion when seeing him trapped. All they could muster was an “Oh, Jon, I’m sorry” void of any actual regret. I mean, SERIOUSLY?! You’re about to watch your friend/boyfriend die AND THAT’S ALL?!
There was more gore, more violence. NO. Bad idea, because now people who haven’t read the comic, and who are expecting a serious movie based on what people have said about, are going to be thrown off by that. The movie won’t be taken seriously now, and it will look like a stupid over sexualized, and super gore Hollywood movie. Sorry, but it’s true.
THE ENDING. I hated it. Yes, it got across the same idea of an alien thing, but, in the word’s of Emily “WE DESERVED A SQUID”. I felt that having the squid, it allowed to show just how in depth Veidt’s planning was. It brings it in slowly, whereas in the movie it was like “Pyramid industries”, and then “OH, IT’S VEIDT. HE WAS COLLECTING DR. MANHATTAN’S POWER”. I mean, how? When? When did he do that? At least with the squid you saw all his planning, how badly he wanted this. I can’t quit figure out how to nicely describe that I don’t like the ending---meaning, making all of what I want to say make sense. So that’s what you have right now.
WHAT I LIKED
I did like what they did with the old Juspecyk (Silk Spectre 1). I liked how they made it more obvious in her character that she was in love with glamour and glitz—in the book it was harder to agree with because of her regular appearance.
I liked Dan a lot, he was just so cute!
I did end up like who they chose as Veidt. They went for a younger lookin guy—smooth move because it makes him seem more hip, more believable to be BFF’s with DAVID BOWIE!! And just great acting on his part.
Overall, I liked the casting for the characters.
That’s about it. I think I’ll like the movie the second time I see just because I’ll go in thinking of it as something else from watchmen. IN SHORT: If you want to enjoy the movie, don’t expect the comic. Expect some other Hollywood movie with a better plot than usual.
Oh, and I have to agree with this:
“Snyder's movie contains more than a few deviations from the beloved original, and the alterations and additions straitjacket the film's ostensible purpose -- to honor the comic -- and dumb it down for a modern movie-going audience that seems to have fallen in love with torture porn.”
http://blog.wired.com/underwire/2009/03/review-watchmen.htmlThis person says it a lot better than I did.
Don’t kill me if you don’t agree. These are MY OWN OPINIONS.